Close exterior view of a timber-and-stone porch with black-framed glass doors and golden larch branches.

Lakeside's Newest Luxury Lots Are Running on Borrowed Water

On Thursday, October 29, Flathead County commissioners voted 2-1 to approve the final plat for Phase I of Territory 1889, the members-only resort Discovery Land Company plans west of U.S. 93 in Lakeside. The vote had been delayed three times because of pending water rights issues. When it finally came, the project's attorney, Bill VanCanagan, told commissioners that "the conditions to the final plat have been met here," and that "there's no requirement in these conditions that a secure water right be obtained," according to the Daily Inter Lake.

That sentence matters for anyone watching Lakeside from a distance. In Montana, a county can approve lots before the water behind them is settled for good. Right now, the largest planned luxury development on Flathead Lake's west shore gets its water from the town's public water district under a contract that runs for seven years. Its own groundwater permit is on hold in court.

A Plat and a Water Right Are Separate Approvals

The subdivision covers about 1,700 acres. At full build-out, Discovery Land Company plans single-family lots, a golf course, a spa, restaurants, retail stores and offices. Phase I covers water, wastewater and stormwater systems for 79 residential lots and 11 open-space lots, out of 359 residential lots planned in total.

The original plan was to supply the subdivision from two groundwater wells on the property. The state permit for those wells became tied up in litigation, so the developers signed an agreement to buy water from the Lakeside County Water and Sewer District and connect to its existing system.

The commissioners' discussion was about who carries the risk if that arrangement runs out. Commissioner Randy Brodehl, who cast the only vote against the plat, said, "We have a gap here that hasn't been filled yet." VanCanagan called the contingency plan "a backstop." Commissioner Pamela Holmquist said the district's letters committing to serve the subdivision put the responsibility on the district rather than the county. The deputy county attorney said the letters put it on the developer.

As the Daily Inter Lake explained in August, the state of Montana owns all surface water and groundwater. A person or entity can hold a legal right to use it. A plat approval and a water right come from different offices and on different schedules.

Lakeside's District Held Far More Water Than It Used

The workaround depends on one fact about Lakeside's own utility. The district holds water rights for about 635 acre-feet a year and, as of August, used about 31% of that, or roughly 197 acre-feet. More than two-thirds of its allocation was going unused.

General Manager Rodney Olson described that surplus to the Daily Inter Lake as an untapped asset: "The water is an asset, and this is a way to leverage that asset. We've never monetized it, and it's just sitting there." He said the revenue could pay for an additional district employee without charging ratepayers.

So the district now earns revenue from capacity it was not using, and the resort gets water it could not yet get on its own. The terms changed between August and the end of October.

Term August 19 lease October 28 agreement
Water allocated 125 acre-feet a year, about 41 million gallons 80 acre-feet a year, about 26.1 million gallons
Phases covered One, two and parts of three One and two only
Length Five years, with two optional one-year extensions Seven years
Payment $81,500 a year during the extension years $52,160 a year, totaling a $365,120 purchase price, plus usage charges

The August figures come from the Daily Inter Lake's report on the original lease. The October terms come from the Flathead Beacon's coverage of the October 28 special meeting, where the board ended the 125-acre-foot lease and approved the smaller agreement, with board member Darcy Lard voting no.

The August lease would have taken the district to 51% use of its rights and committed nearly 20% of its supply for five years. Olson said he was confident the remaining share would be enough. The October agreement is smaller and ends in a purchase rather than a lease. It also no longer covers any part of phase three.

More than 40 ratepayers and community members came to the October 28 meeting, which was held in the district's small conference room and an attached garage, the Beacon reported. Olson described the district's role this way: "We offer sewer and water as a public entity, whether it's to one lot or a subdivision."

How the Seven Years Can End

The October agreement spells out what happens next. It runs in this order:

  1. Now through year seven. Flathead Friends, LLC, a Discovery Land Company subsidiary, pays the district $52,160 a year for 80 acre-feet, covering phases one and two.
  2. If the on-site well permit is approved. The district applied for 249 acre-feet a year, about 81 million gallons, to flow to Territory 1889 through two on-site wells. If those new rights are approved, the district is released from the 80-acre-foot agreement.
  3. If it is not approved by the end of the payment period. Territory 1889 keeps access to the 80 acre-feet but must build an off-site water line connecting its system to the district's.

The third outcome is what the commissioners debated. VanCanagan told them a connection line would be needed only several years from now and would require state DNRC review first. The deputy county attorney said the county is responsible for making sure lots in approved subdivisions have water, and that this scenario "would leave the county on the hook," as the Daily Inter Lake reported.

Eighty acre-feet covers two phases. The full 359-lot plan was built around a 249-acre-foot permit that does not exist yet.

The Permit in Court

The groundwater permit was challenged by Citizens for a Better Flathead, North Shore Water Alliance, Ella Three LLC and a Lakeside resident. The district had applied for 249.42 acre-feet a year on the project's behalf. The petitioners argued that DNRC relied on an outdated 2019 technical memorandum on groundwater availability and did not analyze the effects on existing water users closely enough.

On June 12, Judge Michael McMahon stayed the permit proceeding during judicial review, ordered evidentiary proceedings involving DNRC staff, and transferred the case to Flathead County District Court, the Flathead Beacon reported. That order was an interim ruling and did not decide whether the permit is valid.

A separate application is moving at the state level. On September 21, DNRC's Kalispell office told Flathead Friends LLC that its application, No. 76LJ 30171353, was correct and complete. The letter added that "correct and complete does not mean that your application will be granted," and said the department would issue a draft preliminary determination within 60 days. That window runs to around November 20.

The wastewater side has also had a review. At a June 4 hearing, the Montana Department of Environmental Quality's environmental assessment of Phase I sanitary and water facilities found no significant impact. Wastewater from those lots would go to the district's existing facilities. DEQ also said approving Phase I would not authorize or predetermine later phases, which need their own review.

79 Lots in a Market of 1,103 Listings

For a buyer comparing Lakeside with other Flathead Lake towns, Phase I is small next to the existing market. In September 2026, the Northwest Montana Association of REALTORS counted 1,103 single-family homes for sale across Flathead, Lake and Lincoln counties combined. The single-family median sale price was $712,000, the median days on market was 113, and 190 single-family sales closed. At September's pace, that is close to six months of single-family supply across the three counties, according to NMAR's September 2026 market update.

Seventy-nine lots will not change those numbers much. The larger question for Lakeside is the 280 planned lots beyond Phase I and their timing.

Does the agreement change water use for existing Lakeside district customers? It allocates 80 acre-feet of the district's roughly 635-acre-foot rights to the project and adds consumption-based charges. In 2025, Olson told the Daily Inter Lake that planned rate increases "have absolutely nothing to do with that subdivision" and were tied to upgrades for growth.

This post is general information about public records and local reporting. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the water rights and utility service for any specific property with a qualified attorney, a water rights professional or the DNRC.

At West & Company, Sandra West brings two decades of transaction work to lots, estates and acreage on Flathead Lake. Talk with us about Flathead Lake real estate. Build Your Legacy.

Work With Us

Are you looking to buy or sell in the Western Montana or North Dakota area? We'd love to become your trusted real estate resource. We look forward to connecting with you!

Follow Me on Instagram